Information Assurance and IT Security – an Investment Outlook for 2008
January 17th, 2008January 9, 2008
In 2008, I will be sharing insights, concerns and perspectives on issues of IT security, risk management and information assurance through regular postings in the newsletter, podcasts and blogs.
I thought we’d start ’08 with a review of investment opportunities in the industry. These thoughts will hopefully also have relevance for the infrastructure investments you will likely be considering for your enterprise.
Behind every good investment opportunities are two critical considerations which really boil down to the classical price to earnings, or P/E ratio. On the one hand, we consider where the company is going and what the expectations for growth and profitability are. On the other hand, we must weigh this against current expectations for the company which are reflected in the current price of the company’s shares. Anybody can recognize a nice car, but a good buy is when the price reflects value. Thus, while some security opportunities have very high possibilities, current expectations may already exceed the likely performance of the company making a stock a poor investment even with strong opportunities for the business.
This reflects the state of affair in the security industry. There are some tremendous opportunities, but there are also some highly inflated companies. The prudent and well- informed investor must distinguish between the two.
So let’s start with what’s hot. What drives security spending is threats and more specifically, is actual awareness of these threats. Those that have large potential economic consequences will drive the sales of numerous specialty devices. Unlike most engineering problems, with security, when a solution is found, it is quickly attacked by a variety of alternative attack strategies. The closest experience most engineers have to this kind of environment is trying to tame the flow of water. The reaction to a barrier is always an attempt to get around it!
Hot solutions will be the ones addressing our biggest security issues which for 2008 include privacy, click fraud, compliance, convergence and continuity planning. Throughout the year, we’ll speak to why these are the top plays, but for starters here are some of the drivers:
1) Click fraud – online advertising is growing and most of it is pay-per-click. The only problem is hundreds of millions may be going to fraudulent clicks. There’s a lot of real fungible money here so this will drive sales.
2) Privacy – it’s an election year and this one will be heating up, but on its own may only serve to compliment compliance. 2008 may be the year consumers realize that privacy is something they might be willing to pay for, creating a very hot market for a wide array of technologies including crypto.
3) Compliance – the costs here are more clear cut and look to trump any altruistic interest in security with mandates; special attention here to PCI and the new Minnesota disclosure law will drive spending more than SOX remnants.
4) Continuity Planning – the net is fragile and putting voice onto the net creates a whole set of potential threats including new power dependencies, the need for stronger IP device authentication and lots more … simple thinking about what might be done with a million-node botnet should give reason to invest here.
5) Convergence – while there are plenty of various convergences being bantered about this year, the one with great opportunity is linking physical and logical security. When your alarm system becomes smart, there’s lots of substantial opportunities.
So, these are the problems that will drive spending. Where should you put your money?
Well, here’s the rub. The fastest players to market continue to be agile and focused start-ups. This means the best opportunities are for early stage investments. If you go and ask your IT security team what items top their list, you might just find that the companies behind the technologies are all start-ups. The best opportunities here continue to be for what is commonly the F-Cube (that’s F to the third power representing family, friends and fools) or through Angel Funds (which we’ll see covered throughout the year in the Entrepreneur’s Column).
Venture funds are poised to grab emerging players in this space, but it will usually take a couple years of proving themselves before these companies are rolled up into some of the major public companies where you can play.
However, it’s noteworthy that the public players are extremely acquisitive and everybody from Google, Microsoft and IBM (to list the more focused security players) are buying proven technologies in hopes of scaling them through integration.
This final point is pretty important when you look at many cutting edge security tools today. Right now they usually require complex integration and sophisticated management.
It’s best to think of the market as the auto industry without any car dealers – only auto parts suppliers. The winning technologies, like intermittent windshield wipers won’t make it if you have to build it into a car yourself. However, there will be lots of great products this year that will be proven in the F-500 markets where companies can afford the complexity. Companies that demonstrate success here will be the tools that soon are integrated into the products you buy at Best Buy for your kids to configure and install.